In this article, we are discussing some of the best places to buy baseball cards online. There are numerous online platforms where you can buy baseball cards. Combing the internet to find them can be a difficult task, so we have done that for you.
We have made the task a lot easier by sourcing out twenty different sites and gathering as much information as possible. This article is loaded with enough details, including pros and cons of the best places to buy baseball cards online.
Let’s get straight to it!
Here are 20 popular and reputable websites known for selling baseball cards online.
20 Best Places to Buy Baseball Cards Online
1. eBay
eBay is one of the most well-known and popular online marketplaces for buying and selling a wide variety of products, and also among the best places to buy baseball cards online. With a vast user base and a robust platform, eBay offers a range of options for collectors and enthusiasts to purchase baseball cards from sellers around the world.
When it comes to buying baseball cards on eBay, you’ll find an extensive selection of both modern and vintage cards. From rookie cards to autographed memorabilia, eBay hosts a diverse array of listings that cater to collectors of all levels. Sellers on eBay often provide detailed descriptions, high-resolution images, and condition assessments to help buyers make informed purchasing decisions.
The platform provides various shipping options based on the seller’s preferences and the buyer’s location. Each listing typically includes information about shipping methods, costs, and estimated delivery times. It’s important to review these details before making a purchase to ensure the seller can ship to your location and meet your desired timeline.
To enhance buyer confidence, eBay provides buyer protection programs such as eBay Money Back Guarantee, which helps resolve issues if an item arrives damaged, not as described, or if it doesn’t arrive at all. All these and more makes eBay one of the best places to buy baseball cards online.
Pros
- Secure payment system
- Buyer protection
- Vast selection available
Cons
- Risk of fraud or counterfeit
- Longer shipping times
Shop here
2. Baseball Card Shop
Baseball Card Shop Online is another popular place where to buy baseball cards online. It was founded in 1997 by Steve Hollander. They offer a wide selection of baseball cards, football cards, basketball cards, and hockey cards.
They also sell autographed memorabilia, game-used items, and other sports collectibles. Their website is easy to use, making it easy for customers to find their preferred baseball cards.
Their shipping policy states that orders are typically shipped within 1-2 business days after payment is received. They offer various shipping options, including USPS First Class Mail, USPS Priority Mail, and UPS Ground. They also offer international shipping to select countries. Shipping rates vary depending on the weight and destination of the package. They offer free shipping on orders over $150 within the United States.
They also offer a 30-day return policy on all items, as long as they are returned in their original condition. In summary, they provide a wide range of baseball cards for sale, providing collectors with a vast selection, and with various shipping options and buyer protection programs, they stand out to create a secure and convenient buying experience for baseball card enthusiasts, making Baseball Card Shop is one of the best places to buy baseball cards online.
Pros
- Wide selection
- Detailed product description
- International shipping
Cons
- Tricky return policy
- High shipping costs
Shop here
3. Dean’s Cards
Dean’s Cards was founded in 2001 by Dean Hanley as an online retailer of vintage sports cards and collectibles, specializing in baseball cards. However, they also offer football cards, basketball cards, and hockey cards, as well as autographed memorabilia, game-used items, and other sports collectibles.
They are known for their high-quality vintage cards and collectibles. They have a team of experts who authenticate and grade their items, ensuring that customers receive authentic and accurately graded items.
They offer a wide selection of cards from various years and sets, making it easy for collectors to find the cards they are looking for.
Their website states that they offer international shipping to most countries. Shipping rates vary depending on the weight and destination of the package. They offer various shipping options, including USPS First Class Mail International, USPS Priority Mail International, and USPS Express Mail International.
In addition to selling cards, Dean’s Cards also buys cards and collections from customers. They offer competitive prices and a simple selling process, making it easy for customers to sell their cards. They also offer a 30-day return policy on all items, as long as they are returned in their original condition. This gives customers peace of mind when purchasing items from their website. So you should add them among the best places to buy baseball cards online.
Pros
- High quality vintage cards
- Expert customer service
- Authenticity guarantee
Cons
- It is expensive
- The website isn’t easy to use
Shop here
4. COMC
COMC, which stands for Check Out My Cards, is one of the best places to buy baseball cards online. It is a popular online marketplace for buying, selling, and trading sports cards, including baseball cards. It was founded by Tim Getsch who’s a passionate collector and entrepreneur in 2007.
It was initially created to address the challenges faced by collectors in terms of storage, organization, and selling of their cards.
They offer a vast inventory of baseball cards, including modern and vintage cards, rookie cards, autographs, game-used memorabilia cards, and more. They have a diverse selection that caters to collectors of all levels and budgets. The unique feature of COMC is that sellers can send their physical cards to the company, and COMC takes care of the listing, storage, and shipping processes.
This eliminates the need for individual sellers to manage their own listings and fulfill orders. Buyers can browse the available inventory, add items to their shopping cart, and purchase cards directly from the COMC platform. When shopping here, the company offers consolidated shipping for multiple purchases made from different sellers on their platform.
This means that buyers can purchase cards from multiple sellers and have them shipped together, reducing overall shipping costs. Their meticulous process of card evaluation and grading ensures that the card is authentic and also in great condition, this adds an extra level of assurance for the buyers.
Pros
- Easy to use website
- Large selection
- Consignment service
Cons
- Higher shipping costs
- High prices
Shop here
5. Blowout Cards
Blowout Cards is another popular online retailer specializing in trading cards, including baseball cards. The company was established with the aim of providing collectors with a reliable and customer-centric source for trading cards across various sports, including baseball, and thus was founded in 2007 by Thomas Fish and Jason Eisenberg for this reason.
They have for sale a wide range of baseball cards for sale, catering to collectors of all levels. Their inventory includes cards from different eras, ranging from vintage classics to modern releases. They offer individual cards, complete sets, rookie cards, autographed cards, memorabilia cards, and more.
They are known for their competitive pricing and frequent sales promotions, making it an attractive option for collectors seeking deals on baseball cards. They often have special promotions, discounts, and exclusive releases to provide customers with added value. The company emphasizes customer service and strives to create a positive buying experience for collectors.
They have a user-friendly website with detailed product descriptions and high-resolution images to help customers make informed purchasing decisions. Additionally, Blowout Cards offers various payment options, including credit card payments and PayPal, for convenient transactions.
Overall, Blowout Cards has gained a strong reputation as a reliable and customer-oriented online retailer for baseball cards and other trading cards. Their diverse inventory, competitive pricing, and commitment to customer satisfaction have made them one of the best places to buy baseball cards online.
Pros
- Great customer service
- Pre-Order Options
- Competitive pricing
Cons
- High shipping costs
- Limited availability
Shop here
6.Beckett Marketplace
Beckett Marketplace is a leading marketplace that specializes in the sale of baseball cards. They sell a wide range of baseball cards from different eras and manufacturers, including vintage, modern, and autographed cards. Beckett Marketplace has a user-friendly website that allows customers to easily search for and purchase the cards they are looking for.
They are known for their high-quality grading services, which provide an objective assessment of a card’s condition and value. They offer a range of grading options, from the basic raw card review to the more detailed grading services that provide a more comprehensive assessment of the card’s condition. In addition to selling baseball cards, they also provide a range of other products and services related to the hobby.
They offer price guides, which provide up-to-date pricing information for baseball cards, as well as magazines and books that cover the latest news and trends in the hobby. They also offer a 30-day return policy on all purchases, which gives customers the peace of mind that they can return any items that they are not satisfied with.
Pros
- User friendly website
- High quality grading service
- 30 days return policy
Cons
- Expensive grading service
- High shipping
Shop here
7. Sports Card Direct
Sports Card Direct is a popular place to buy baseball cards online f baseball cards. They provide a wide range of baseball cards from different eras and manufacturers, including vintage, modern, and autographed cards. They also offer graded and ungraded cards, as well as complete sets.
Their competitive pricing makes them a great option for customers who are looking for good deals on baseball cards. They also offer a rewards program that allows customers to earn points on their purchases, which can be redeemed for discounts on future purchases. Like Beckett Marketplace, they also provide a range of other products and services related to the hobby. They offer price guides, which provide up-to-date pricing information for baseball cards, as well as magazines and books that cover the latest news and trends in the hobby. Overall, Sports Card Direct is a great option for anyone who is interested in buying or selling baseball cards.
Pros
- Wide range of cards
- Reward program
- 30 days return policy
Cons
- Sketchy information history
- High shipping costs
Shop here
8. Dave & Adam’s Card World
Dave & Adam’s Card World is a leading online retailer of sports cards, gaming cards, and collectibles. The company was founded in 1991 by Dave Silver and Adam Martin, two friends who shared a passion for collecting sports cards.
They started by selling cards out of their dorm room at the University at Buffalo and have since grown into a multi-million dollar business.
This store specializes in the sale of baseball cards, offering a wide range of cards from different eras and manufacturers, this includes vintage, modern, and autographed cards. Graded and ungraded cards are also available , as well as complete sets.
In addition to baseball cards. Their commitment to customer service sets them apart from other retailers.
Here, there’s a team of knowledgeable staff available to assist customers with whatever they desire. Another thing that sets Dave & Adam’s Card World apart from other retailers is their fast and reliable shipping.
They offer free shipping on all orders over $199 within the United States, and they use a variety of shipping methods to ensure that orders are delivered quickly and safely. They also offer international shipping to customers outside of the United States.
Pros
- 30 days return policy
- Competitive pricing
- Wide range of options
Cons
- High shipping costs
- Tricky shipping policy
Shop here
9. Steel City Collectibles
Steel City Collectibles is a well-known retailer store specializing in trading cards and collectibles, including baseball cards. And also, among the best places to buy baseball cards online. The company was founded with the aim of providing collectors with a wide range of trading cards and collectibles, it is based in McKeesport, Pennsylvania, and operates primarily as an online retailer, offering a comprehensive selection of sports cards, gaming cards, non-sports cards, memorabilia, and supplies.
They carry products from major trading card manufacturers such as Topps, Panini, Upper Deck, and Leaf. Their diverse selection of baseball card products, including individual packs, boxes, sets, and specialty releases like autographed cards, game-used memorabilia cards, rookie cards, and graded cards stands them out form competition. They strive to provide collectors with a wide availability of baseball card products.
They often carry current releases, as well as popular and sought-after vintage cards. They also buy cards and collections from collectors, offering competitive prices for valuable and sought-after cards, helping collectors monetize their collections.
They typically provide clear instructions on how to sell cards or collections to them, including the submission process, pricing evaluation, and payment methods.
Pros
- Excellent customer service
- Competitive pricing
- User-friendly online shopping experience.
Cons
- Sketchy information history
- Limited stock
Shop here
10. Burbank Sports Cards
Burbank Sports Cards is a top online store specializing in sports cards, including baseball cards. It was founded in 1986 by Rob Veres, a passionate sports card collector. The company initially operated as a small storefront in Burbank, California, with a focus on selling sports cards and collectibles.
Over the years, Burbank Sports Cards expanded its operations and transitioned into a highly regarded online retailer, serving customers worldwide.
They have a strong presence in the baseball card market, offering an extensive selection of baseball cards, including individual cards, packs, boxes, complete sets, autographed cards, game-used memorabilia cards, rookie cards, and graded cards.
They strive to maintain a diverse and up-to-date inventory of baseball cards to cater to the demands of collectors. They regularly stock current releases, as well as sought-after vintage cards, ensuring a wide range of options for collectors with varying preferences and budgets. They provide a range of services related to graded cards, which are professionally assessed for condition and authenticity by third-party grading companies like PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator) and BGS (Beckett Grading Services).
In addition to selling baseball cards, Burbank Sports Cards also buys cards and collections from collectors. They may offer competitive prices for valuable and desirable cards, providing an avenue for collectors to sell their items.
Pros
- Grading services
- Buy back services
- Multiple payment methods
Cons
- Unresponsive customer service
- High prices
Shop here
11. Proxibid
Proxibid is another online store offering a wide range of products, including sports cards and memorabilia. They are known for their competitive pricing and their commitment to customer service.
They have available a wide range of baseball cards from different eras and manufacturers, including graded and ungraded cards, complete sets, and autographed cards.
They are dedicated to customer service and so, have on hand a team of helpful staff that are available to answer any questions or concerns that customers may have. They also offer a 30-day return policy on all purchases, which gives customers the peace of mind that they can return any items that they are not satisfied with.
This store uses a secure and reliable payment system, and they also use a variety of payment methods to ensure that transactions are safe and secure, including credit cards, PayPal, and wire transfers. Whether you are a seasoned collector or just starting out, Proxibid is a great place to find the cards you are looking for.
All these and more makes this store one of the best places to buy baseball cards online.
Pros
- Competitive pricing
- Excellent customer service
- Reliable payment system.
Cons
- High shipping costs
- The website isn’t easy to use
Shop here
12. Huggins & Scott Auctions
Huggins & Scott Auctions is one of the best places to buy baseball cards online. It is a prominent auction house specializing in sports memorabilia, including the sale of baseball cards. Huggins & Scott Auctions has established itself as a trusted name in the sports memorabilia auction industry.
With a history dating back to 1990, the company has become renowned for its high-quality auctions that feature a wide range of sports collectibles, including baseball cards. Baseball card auctions by Huggins & Scott offer collectors and enthusiasts a platform to buy and sell a diverse array of cards, ranging from vintage to modern releases.
The auction house handles various types of baseball cards, including rookie cards, graded cards, autographed cards, complete sets, rare and scarce cards, and high-end premium cards. They take great care in curating their auctions, ensuring that the items up for bid are thoroughly vetted and accurately described.
They provide detailed descriptions and high-resolution images of each baseball card to assist potential bidders in making informed decisions. Their auctions typically feature a wide selection of baseball cards, including those from different eras and players of significance.
From pre-war cards featuring legends like Babe Ruth and Ty Cobb to modern-day stars like Mike Trout and Juan Soto, Huggins & Scott Auctions caters to a diverse range of collectors’ interests.
Pros
- Cheap pricing
- Rare cards available
- Safe and secure
Cons
- Potential price inflation
- Limited inspection
Shop here
13. Collector’s Corner
Collector’s Corner is a well-established place to buy baseball cards online. It is one of the best stores online for baseball cards. There is a wide range of products and services available here, this includes vintage and modern baseball cards, autographed cards, graded and ungraded cards, and complete sets.
One of the things that sets Collector’s Corner apart from other online marketplaces is their focus on customer service. They have a team of knowledgeable customer service representatives who are always on hand to answer customer’s questions or enquiries. They also offer a 30-day return policy on all purchases, which gives customers the opportunity to return any items that they are not satisfied with.
There are a variety of payment methods to ensure that transactions are safe and secure, including credit cards, PayPal, and wire transfers. They also offer competitive pricing and the ability to bid on items in real-time auctions.
Overall, Collector’s Corner is a great option for anyone who is interested in buying or selling baseball cards. They offer a wide range of products and services, competitive pricing, and excellent customer service. Whether you are a seasoned collector or just starting out, Collector’s Corner is a great place to find the cards you are looking for.
Pros
- Wide range of cards
- Great customer service
- Reliable payment method
Cons
- Possibility of inflated prices
- High shipping costs
Shop here
14. Topps
Topps is a renowned American store that has played a significant role in the sale of baseball cards for decades. It was founded in 1938 by brothers Abram, Ira, Philip, and Joseph Shorin as a family-run business. Initially named “Topps Chewing Gum Inc.,” the company started by producing bubble gum and trading cards as promotional items for their gum products.
In 1950, Topps released its first baseball card set, launching a new era for the company in the sports card industry. Topps is widely recognized as a leading producer of baseball cards, having released numerous iconic sets and cards over the years.
The company has held licenses with Major League Baseball (MLB) and the Major League Baseball Players Association (MLBPA) to produce official baseball cards featuring current players, rookies, legends, and special editions.
They have been at the forefront of various innovations in the baseball card industry, including introducing glossy cards, full-color photos, player statistics, and other features that enhanced the collecting experience. In
recent years, Topps has embraced the digital space by introducing digital trading cards and collectibles through their Topps Digital Apps. These apps allow collectors to acquire, trade, and showcase digital versions of their favorite cards.
Pros
- Iconic designs
- Wide selection
- Rich heritage and legacy
Cons
- Limited licensing
- Counterfeit concerns
Shop here
15. PSA
PSA also known as Professional Sports Authenticator is a leading third-party grading and authentication service specializing in sports cards, including baseball cards. They provide professional grading and authentication services for baseball cards and other sports cards.
It is highly regarded in the sports card industry for its reputation and credibility. Their grading and authentication services are widely recognized and trusted by collectors, dealers, and investors.
They authenticate the legitimacy of the card, ensuring that it is not a counterfeit or altered item. They carry a premium in the market due to the assurance of quality and authenticity provided by their grading process. Grading involves evaluating the condition of a card and assigning it a grade on a scale from 1 to 10, with 10 being the highest.
The grading process considers factors such as centering, corners, edges, and surface quality. They operate the PSA Set Registry, an online platform that allows collectors to showcase and compete for the best sets of graded cards. Collectors here can create set registries for various baseball card sets, track their progress, and compare their collections with others.
It fosters a competitive and community-driven environment for collectors. The popularity of PSA grading has grown significantly, resulting in a large number of cards being submitted for grading. This can lead to longer turnaround times for grading services and increased competition for obtaining high-grade cards.
Pros
- Credibility and trust
- Standardized grading
- Increased market value
Cons
- High costs
- Availability concerns
Shop here
16. Heritage Auctions
Heritage Auctions is one of the best places where to buy baseball cards online. It is among the largest auction houses in the world and is known for its sales of rare and valuable items, including baseball cards. They offer a wide range of products and services, including vintage and modern baseball cards, graded and ungraded cards, autographed cards, and complete sets.
One of the things that sets Heritage Auctions apart from other auction houses is their focus on transparency and authenticity. They have a team of experts who thoroughly examine and authenticate all items before they are put up for auction.
This helps to ensure that buyers are getting authentic items and that sellers are getting fair prices for their items. Heritage Auctions also offers a variety of bidding options to ensure that buyers can bid on items in a way that is convenient for them. They offer live bidding, absentee bidding, and online bidding, which allows buyers to bid on items from anywhere in the world.
Overall, Heritage Auctions is a great option for anyone who is interested in buying or selling baseball cards. They offer a wide range of products and services, competitive pricing, and a focus on authenticity and transparency. Whether you are a seasoned collector or just starting out, Heritage Auctions is a great place to find the cards you are looking for.
Pros
- Wide range of products
- Excellent customer service
- 30 days return policy
Cons
- Competitive bidding process
- High shipping fees
Shop here
17. Sports Memorabilia
Sports Memorabilia is another leading online store that deals in sports memorabilia, baseball cards included. The company was founded in 1996 and has since grown to become one of the largest online retailers of sports memorabilia in the world. They make available a wide range of products, including vintage and modern baseball cards, graded and ungraded cards, autographed cards, and complete sets.
They also offer a variety of other sports memorabilia items, such as jerseys, helmets, and photographs. They set themselves apart from other online marketplaces by their commitment to customer service, they also offer a 100% lifetime authenticity guarantee on all items, which means that customers can be confident that they are getting authentic items. They also offer a 100% satisfaction guarantee, which means that customers can return any items that they are not satisfied with for a full refund. International shipping is available to many countries around the world.
They use a variety of shipping carriers to ensure that items are delivered quickly and securely.
Overall, this is a great option for anyone who is interested in buying or selling baseball cards and other sports memorabilia. Their a wide range of products and services offering, plus competitive pricing, a commitment to customer service and authenticity. Whether you are a seasoned collector or just starting out,
This is a great place to find the cards and memorabilia you are looking for. All these and more makes this store one of the best places to buy baseball cards online.
Pros
- Multiple payment methods
- International shipping
- Authenticity guarantee
Cons
- Exorbitant shipping costs
- Competitive bidding process
Shop here
18. Just Collect
Just Collect is a reputable online store with focus in the buying and selling of vintage baseball cards and other sports memorabilia. It was founded in 2005 by Leighton Sheldon, a passionate collector and entrepreneur.
The company started as a small operation in Somerset, New Jersey, with a focus on buying and selling vintage sports cards. It is primarily known for its expertise in vintage baseball cards. They specialize in cards from the pre-war era through the 1980s. The company offers a wide range of baseball cards, including rookie cards, Hall of Fame cards, complete sets, graded cards, and high-demand vintage cards.
They carefully evaluate the condition and authenticity of the cards they sell, ensuring that collectors can trust the quality and value of their purchases. International shipping services available, allowing collectors from around the world to purchase their baseball cards. This company works with reliable shipping partners to ensure safe and secure delivery of the cards to international destinations.
International customers can directly inquire about shipping rates, options, and any customs or import requirements specific to their country. Their reputation in the sports card collecting community. Their commitment to honesty, expertise, and exceptional customer service has contributed to their success.
Whether you are a seasoned collector or a novice enthusiast, Just Collect provides a trusted platform for buying and selling vintage baseball cards, offering a wide selection of cards and ensuring a seamless international purchasing experience.
Pros
- Quality and authenticity
- Customer service
- Selection of vintage cards
Cons
- Availability of specific cards
- Potential selling fees
Shop here
19. Baseball Card Exchange
Baseball Card Exchange is another place. where to buy baseball cards online. It is a leading company dealing in the buying and selling of vintage baseball cards and other sports memorabilia. The company was founded in 1990 by Steve Hart, who started out as a collector and dealer of vintage baseball cards. At Baseball Card Exchange apart from other sports memorabilia companies, their focus is on authenticity.
They have a team of experts who carefully examine and grade each item to ensure that it is authentic and in the condition that is advertised. They also offer a lifetime authenticity guarantee on all items, which means that customers can be confident that they are getting authentic items.
They offer fair prices for both buyers and sellers, and they are willing to negotiate prices to ensure that both parties are satisfied. They also have a user-friendly website that is easy to navigate and search for specific items. Summarily, Baseball Card Exchange is a great option for anyone who is interested in buying or selling vintage baseball cards and other sports memorabilia.
They offer a wide range of products and services, competitive pricing, and a commitment to authenticity and customer service. Whether you are a seasoned collector or just starting out, Baseball Card Exchange is a great place to find the cards and memorabilia you are looking for.
Pros
- Verification services
- Authenticity and preservation
- Wide variety of items
Cons
- Limited inventory
- Limited focus
Shop here
20. Layton Sports Cards
Layton Sports Cards is one of the best places to buy baseball cards online. It is well-known retailer specializing in the sale of sports cards, baseball cards included. The company was founded in 2008 by Layton and Renee Jones, a husband and wife team based in Altamonte Springs, Florida.
What started as a small hobby quickly grew into a successful business, driven by their passion for sports cards and the desire to provide collectors with a wide selection of quality products. They provide a diverse range of baseball cards, catering to collectors of all levels and interests.
They carry a variety of products, including individual cards, packs, boxes, sets, autographed cards, memorabilia cards, and graded cards. The company focuses on both modern and vintage baseball cards, ensuring that collectors have access to cards from different eras and players of significance.
They strive to provide competitive pricing, quality service, and a user-friendly online shopping experience. International shipping services are available, allowing collectors from around the world to purchase their favorite baseball cards. It’s important to note that international shipping costs, delivery times, and potential customs fees may vary based on the destination and the value of the purchased items. They have gained a solid reputation in the sports card collecting community.
Their commitment to customer service, competitive pricing, and a wide selection of baseball cards has contributed to their success. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a new enthusiast, Layton Sports Cards has proven to be a trusted platform for buying baseball cards, with a focus on meeting the needs of collectors both domestically and internationally.
Pros
- Wide selection
- Quality service
- Established reputation
Cons
- Limited inventory availability
- High shipping costs
Shop here
Also Read: Best Places to Buy Antiques Online at Discount 2023
Summary
So far, we have been able to review twenty different stores that buy and sell baseball cards. If you are a collector, you might want to read this article thoroughly, it would be very useful to you. Therefore, these are all the best places to buy baseball cards online.
Please note that availability and pricing may vary on these platforms, so it’s always a good idea to compare options and check for specific cards or deals you are interested in.
I hope you enjoyed reading this piece as much as I enjoyed writing it. Kindly give us feedbacks in the comment section.
Thanks!